Asktopus case study: named in 0 of 110 AI answers
We tracked Asktopus, our own AI chatbot, on 16 buyer questions in 7 AI engines. It was named in 0 of 110 answers, its top competitor in 67%. Method and data.
What we found
On 6 October 2026 we asked seven AI engines 16 questions that buyers of a website chatbot ask, in English, Danish and Spanish. None of the 110 answers named Asktopus, our own AI chatbot (95% interval 0% to 3.4%), and none cited asktopus.com, while Tidio was named in 69 of 103 answers (67%) and Intercom in 68 of 103 (66%). The site scored 91 of 100 in our GEO audit, so crawlers can read it: the engines cited competitors' own sites and other vendors' comparison posts instead.
- answers named Asktopus
- 0 of 110
- named Tidio, the most named competitor
- 69 of 103
- GEO audit score for asktopus.com
- 91 of 100
- cited a page on asktopus.com
- 0 of 110
Why track our own product?
Asktopus is an AI chatbot for websites, made by Uneven Bits, the company behind sirefs. We run sirefs on our own products before anyone else's, because we know them well enough to check every number by hand. This is the first run on Asktopus, reported in full: the prompts, the engines, every denominator and what the data recommends.
We make both products, so we have an interest in the result. That's why every number below comes with its denominator and interval, and all 16 prompts are listed at the end.
How was the study set up?
| Setting | Value |
|---|---|
| Collected | 6 October 2026, one run, 15:23 to 15:39 UTC |
| Read from the dashboard | 8 October 2026 |
| Prompts | 16, written by us |
| Markets | United States in English (12 prompts), Denmark in Danish (3), Spain in Spanish (1) |
| Engines | 7: ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude and Grok |
| Cadence | Weekly. This page covers the first run only. |
| Answers | 110 |
Which questions did we ask?
The ones a buyer asks before choosing a chatbot: which is best, what the alternatives to well-known tools are, what it costs, and whether a tool handles a specific need. Topics run from general best-of questions to ecommerce, pricing, answering from your own content, GDPR and handing a conversation to a human.
Twelve of the 16 prompts name no brand. Four ask for alternatives to a named competitor (Chatbase, Tidio, Intercom Fin and Karla). None names Asktopus. The full list is at the end of this page.
| Intent | Prompts | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Best | 7 | "best ai chatbot for website" |
| Alternatives | 4 | "What are good alternatives to Tidio?" |
| Pricing | 2 | "How much does an AI chatbot for a website cost?" |
| For a use case | 2 | "Is there a GDPR compliant AI chatbot for my website?" |
| How to | 1 | "Which AI customer service chatbot can answer questions from my own website content?" |
Which engines, and how were the answers collected?
| Engine | Method | What sirefs collected | Answers |
|---|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT | ui | The answer chatgpt.com gives a logged-out visitor | 16 |
| Google AI Overviews | serp | The AI Overview on Google's results page | 16 |
| Google AI Mode | serp | Google's AI Mode answer for the prompt | 14 |
| Gemini | ui | The answer the Gemini app gives a logged-out visitor | 16 |
| Perplexity | api | Perplexity's Sonar API, until the app collector is connected | 16 |
| Claude | api | Anthropic's API with web search | 16 |
| Grok | api | xAI's API with web search | 16 |
Microsoft's engines weren't collected when this study ran (Copilot from 20 October to 3 November 2026, Bing AI Mode since 8 November 2026), so neither is in it. How sirefs collects answers explains each method.
Why 110 answers and not 112 (16 prompts on 7 engines)? Two Google AI Mode answers never loaded: Google returned an answer block with nothing in it. They aren't counted, and sirefs now asks again when that happens. Two Google searches showed no AI Overview at all; those do count, as answers without a mention, because that's what a searcher saw.
How did we count?
A brand is mentioned when its name or an alias appears in the answer, found either by name matching or by a language model reading the answer. A brand named in the question doesn't count for that question, which is why some denominators are below 110. Every rate comes with a 95% Wilson interval: the range the true rate very likely falls in. Reading the numbers explains the method.
We also read the answers behind the counts, and found two problems, both fixed on 8 October 2026. First, in three Grok answers the language model listed tracked brands the answers never name, and the dashboard counted them: 14 mentions in all, including a single Asktopus mention. A brand the language model lists now counts only when its name is in the answer's text. Second, we started that first run twice by mistake, so 26 checks were asked twice, minutes apart, and both answers counted. Only the first counts now, and a check that ran in the last hour isn't run again. This page first went out with 138 answers; every number here is the corrected count, the same as the demo's.
How often did the engines name Asktopus?
Never. Asktopus was named in 0 of 110 answers (95% interval 0% to 3.4%). asktopus.com was cited in 0 of 110, although 104 answers cited at least one page.
| Engine | Method | Asktopus named | 95% interval | Tidio named | 95% interval |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT | ui | 0 of 16 | 0% to 19% | 10 of 15 | 42% to 85% |
| Google AI Overviews | serp | 0 of 16 | 0% to 19% | 10 of 15 | 42% to 85% |
| Google AI Mode | serp | 0 of 14 | 0% to 22% | 9 of 13 | 42% to 87% |
| Gemini | ui | 0 of 16 | 0% to 19% | 10 of 15 | 42% to 85% |
| Perplexity | api | 0 of 16 | 0% to 19% | 7 of 15 | 25% to 70% |
| Claude | api | 0 of 16 | 0% to 19% | 8 of 15 | 30% to 75% |
| Grok | api | 0 of 16 | 0% to 19% | 15 of 15 | 80% to 100% |
| All engines | 0 of 110 | 0% to 3.4% | 69 of 103 | 57% to 75% |
Read the engine rows with care: 14 to 16 answers can't pin a rate down. Zero of 16 is consistent with a true rate anywhere up to 19%. The pooled figure is the firm one: across 110 answers, the true rate is very likely under 3.4%.
The markets tell the same story: 0 of 82 US English answers (0% to 4.5%), 0 of 21 Danish (0% to 15%) and 0 of 7 Spanish (0% to 35%). Asktopus is made in Copenhagen, and the Danish answers didn't name it either.
Rank doesn't apply: a brand that's never named has no position.
Who did the engines name instead?
At least one of the nine competitors we track was named in 100 of the 108 answers with text (93%, 86% to 96%).
| Brand | Named in | Rate | 95% interval | Average position in lists |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tidio | 69 of 103 | 67% | 57% to 75% | 2.3 (64 lists) |
| Intercom | 68 of 103 | 66% | 56% to 74% | 3.4 (57 lists) |
| Zendesk | 50 of 110 | 45% | 36% to 55% | 4.4 (31 lists) |
| Chatbase | 38 of 103 | 37% | 28% to 47% | 2.7 (36 lists) |
| Botpress | 30 of 110 | 27% | 20% to 36% | 3.4 (29 lists) |
| Crisp | 25 of 110 | 23% | 16% to 31% | 3.2 (24 lists) |
| Gorgias | 24 of 110 | 22% | 15% to 30% | 2.8 (23 lists) |
| Chatling | 8 of 110 | 7% | 3.7% to 14% | 3.5 (8 lists) |
| Karla | 0 of 103 | 0% | 0% to 3.6% | None |
| Asktopus | 0 of 110 | 0% | 0% to 3.4% | None |
Tidio came first in 29 list-style answers, more than any other brand, and the engines recommended it, not just named it, in 62 of the 101 answers the language model read (61%, 52% to 70%). Positions move a lot from one answer to the next, so read them as a tendency.
The engines also named brands we don't track. SiteGPT was named in 21 of the 108 answers the model read, by five engines, and recommended in 18: nearly as often as Gorgias and Crisp were named. Boei (13 answers), eesel AI (10), Freshdesk (10), tawk.to (10) and CustomGPT.ai (10) followed.
Which sources did the engines cite?
104 of the 110 answers cited at least one page, and none was on asktopus.com. The nine domains cited in 10 or more answers all belong to companies that sell chatbots or support software: four we track, and five we don't, cited mostly for blog posts that compare tools.
| Domain | Whose site | Answers citing it | Engines citing it |
|---|---|---|---|
| sitegpt.ai | SiteGPT (not tracked) | 22 | 6 |
| tidio.com | Tidio | 20 | 6 |
| chatbase.co | Chatbase | 18 | 6 |
| boei.help | Boei (not tracked) | 16 | 5 |
| chatbot.com | ChatBot (not tracked) | 16 | 4 |
| intercom.com | Intercom | 16 | 4 |
| eesel.ai | eesel AI (not tracked) | 13 | 6 |
| botpress.com | Botpress | 10 | 5 |
| wonderchat.io | Wonderchat (not tracked) | 10 | 4 |
No answer named Asktopus, so every one of these sources appeared next to competitors and never next to us. The single most cited page was a Boei post on the best AI chatbot builders of 2026, in 7 answers. No domain was cited by all seven engines.
Beyond the vendors, Reddit (9 answers) and YouTube (8) were cited only by Google AI Overviews and AI Mode, and G2 by four engines (7). In Danish, two local sites were cited: chatassist.dk in 8 answers, for its pages on Karla alternatives, prices and Danish chatbots, and businesswith.dk in 6, half of them for its Karla alternatives page.
What did the GEO audit find?
The audit reads a site the way an AI crawler does. asktopus.com scored 91 of 100 on 6 October 2026.
| Area | Score |
|---|---|
| Access: can AI engines reach the site? | 100 |
| Readability: can they read it without JavaScript? | 100 |
| Content: is it easy to quote? | 100 |
| Identity: do they know who it is? | 81 |
| Presence: is the brand known elsewhere? | 0 |
The site publishes llms.txt, a crawlable pricing page, FAQ and product markup, and 18 comparison or alternatives pages. It lost points for having no sameAs links to its profiles and no Wikidata entry. None of its pages was cited in this run. The audit says whether engines can read and trust a site, not whether they'll choose it, and here they didn't.
What did the answers say?
Three examples from 6 October 2026, quoted as collected.
For most small-business websites, I’d pick Tidio. It’s a good balance of AI, live chat, ease of setup, and price.
ChatGPT (ui), United States, English. Prompt: "What is the best AI chatbot for a small business website?"
The best AI chatbot for your website depends on your technical skill and main goal, with ChatBot offering the easiest all-in-one setup for general customer service.
Google AI Overviews (serp), United States, English. Prompt: "best ai chatbot for website". The only source for that sentence was chatbot.com, ChatBot's own site.
Hvis du ikke allerede har et kundeservicesystem, ville jeg starte med Tidio/Lyro.
"If you don't already have a customer service system, I'd start with Tidio/Lyro." ChatGPT (ui), Denmark, Danish. Prompt: "Hvad er den bedste AI chatbot til en hjemmeside?" Its comparison table listed five tools, all on our competitor list: Intercom Fin, Tidio, Chatbase, Zendesk AI and Botpress.
What does it mean?
A well-built site wasn't enough. In this category, the engines answered from a short list of established brands and from comparison posts that vendors write about each other. Asktopus has comparison pages of its own; the engines cited other people's.
For anyone deciding whether this kind of tracking is worth it: none of this shows up in web analytics. A buyer who asks ChatGPT and gets five names that aren't yours never reaches your site. You only see the gap by asking the questions, on every engine, with enough answers to trust the number.
What does the data recommend?
These are the dashboard's next steps for the project on 8 October 2026, worked out from the answers above. They're recommendations. Nothing on this page shows whether they work: that takes later runs and a significance test.
- Answer three questions where every answer names a competitor. "What are the best Chatbase alternatives?" (all 7 answers; Intercom and Botpress in 7 each), "best ai chatbot for website" (all 7; Intercom in 7) and "What are good alternatives to Tidio?" (all 7; Intercom, Crisp and Zendesk in 7 each). The answers show the format the engines quote and the pages they cite.
- Track the brands the engines name. SiteGPT (21 answers, recommended in 18) and Boei (13 answers, recommended in 11) weren't on the competitor list. Their sites are among the most cited too, so tracking them shows where they win. We did this on 8 October, so the demo tracks eleven competitors, not the nine in this study, and its next steps have moved on.
- Get mentioned on the sites the engines cite. ringly.io, which sells AI phone support to Shopify brands, was cited in 8 answers for its list of the best Shopify chatbots, and YouTube in 8, none of which named Asktopus.
- Take part where the conversation is cited. Google AI Mode cited the Reddit thread "Top 3 AI Chatbots for E-commerce SMBs in 2026" in 2 answers. If you can genuinely help there, reply as yourself.
The audit adds one fix: list the brand's real profiles in the sameAs field of the site's Organization markup.
What are the limits of this study?
- One run, one day. All 110 answers were collected on 6 October 2026, within 16 minutes. It's a snapshot, not a trend. The project runs weekly; later runs aren't on this page.
- Sample size. 110 answers give a firm result for Asktopus overall, but each engine gave 14 to 16 answers and the Spanish market 7, so per-engine and per-market rates have wide intervals.
- Methods differ. ChatGPT and Gemini are logged-out app answers, and Google's two are what its results page showed. Perplexity, Claude and Grok answered through their APIs (Sonar, Claude Haiku 4.5 and Grok 4.3), which often cite different pages and name different brands than the apps do. Microsoft's engines aren't covered.
- One product, one niche. Website chatbots is a category with large, well-known players, and we wrote the 16 prompts. Another product, category or prompt set could look very different.
- What counts as a mention. Any naming counts, including passing ones, such as Zendesk named as a place to send escalations. Recommendations and positions come from a language model's reading and are noisier than mention counts.
- Our own product. We make Asktopus and sirefs, so we have an interest in the result. The prompts, denominators and intervals are all on this page.
How can you check these numbers?
The 16 prompts are listed below: ask them in the same engines and compare. Answers vary from run to run, so expect a similar picture rather than the same words. The answers in this study are dated 6 October 2026.
The live demo shows the same dashboard on another of our products, CompanyData in English: every answer with its engine, method, market and date, the competitors, cited sources, next steps and audit. It showed this Asktopus project until 12 October 2026.
To see how ready your own site is, the free check audits it for AI engines, with no sign-up. To track your brand on every engine like this, see the plans.
All 16 prompts
| # | Prompt | Market | Intent | Topic |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | What is the best AI chatbot for a small business website? | US, English | Best | General |
| 2 | best ai chatbot for website | US, English | Best | General |
| 3 | Which AI chatbot should I use for my webshop? | US, English | Best | Ecommerce |
| 4 | best AI chatbot for a Shopify store | US, English | Best | Ecommerce |
| 5 | What are the best Chatbase alternatives? | US, English | Alternatives | Alternatives |
| 6 | What are good alternatives to Tidio? | US, English | Alternatives | Alternatives |
| 7 | Intercom Fin alternatives for small businesses | US, English | Alternatives | Alternatives |
| 8 | Is there a GDPR compliant AI chatbot for my website? | US, English | For a use case | GDPR |
| 9 | How much does an AI chatbot for a website cost? | US, English | Pricing | Pricing |
| 10 | Which AI customer service chatbot can answer questions from my own website content? | US, English | How to | Own content |
| 11 | best RAG chatbot for a website | US, English | Best | Own content |
| 12 | AI chatbot that hands conversations over to a human by email | US, English | For a use case | Human handoff |
| 13 | Hvad er den bedste AI chatbot til en hjemmeside? ("What's the best AI chatbot for a website?") | Denmark, Danish | Best | General |
| 14 | Hvad koster en AI chatbot til hjemmesiden? ("What does an AI chatbot for the website cost?") | Denmark, Danish | Pricing | Pricing |
| 15 | Hvilke alternativer er der til Karla chatbot? ("What alternatives are there to the Karla chatbot?") | Denmark, Danish | Alternatives | Alternatives |
| 16 | ¿Cuál es el mejor chatbot con IA para una página web? ("What's the best AI chatbot for a website?") | Spain, Spanish | Best | General |
Frequently asked questions
Why publish a study where our own product scores zero?
Because that's what the data showed. A zero with 110 answers behind it is a firm starting point: later runs can be tested against it, and the answers show what to work on.
Does a high GEO audit score get you into AI answers?
Not on its own. asktopus.com scored 91 of 100 and was named in none of 110 answers. The audit checks whether engines can reach, read and trust a site; it doesn't predict whether they'll name it.
Why do some brands have fewer than 110 answers?
Answers to a question that names a brand don't count for that brand. Every answer to "What are good alternatives to Tidio?" mentions Tidio: that's the question, not visibility. So Tidio's rate uses 103 answers.
Can I see the answers myself?
Not in the demo any more. It showed these answers until 12 October 2026, when it moved to CompanyData, another of our products. The live demo now shows every CompanyData answer the same way, with its engine, method, market and date, counted by the same code.
How we made this case study
Every number comes from sirefs' public demo of the Asktopus project, read on 8 October 2026, and from reading the answers behind it. Intervals are 95% Wilson score intervals, computed the way the dashboard computes them. Spotted a mistake? Write to support@sirefs.com.